Lawyer loses bid to stop DCI probe over Sh5m land sale


Lawyer loses bid to stop DCI probe over Sh5m land sale

Lawyer loses bid to stop DCI probe over Sh5m land sale [Photo;Joakim Bwana/Standard]                                                                                                                                                                      


The High Court has declined to stop the Directorate of Criminal Investigations (DCI) from summoning, investigating or arresting a Coast-based lawyer linked to a dispute over the sale of land worth Sh5 million.

Justice Jairus Ngaah ruled that Jane Onyango had failed to demonstrate that the DCI’s decision to investigate or summon her for questioning was illegal, irrational, procedurally unfair or motivated by malice or an ulterior motive.

Onyango had sought orders barring the DCI and other investigative agencies from arresting or charging her over the transaction. However, Justice Ngaah noted that the DPP, who independently decides whether to prosecute, was not a party to the case and could not be bound by the court’s orders.

“More fundamentally, prohibition is directed at a decision that is about to be made unlawfully. There is no evidence that a decision to arrest or charge the Applicant has been made, or is imminent. The investigation is ongoing, and its outcome may well be that no charge is recommended against her,” he said.

The judge added that barring future prosecution would pre-empt the DPP’s independent mandate under Article 157(10) of the Constitution and amount to an acquittal before any charges had been brought.

He said he would not have quashed the further summons, even if presented in court, as the investigating officer’s explanation for issuing it was reasonable and unchallenged. “If a decision is ultimately made to charge the Applicant and she considers it unlawful, she will be at liberty to challenge it on the material then available,” he said, rejecting the argument that police must provide written reasons and disclose evidence before questioning a person of interest, saying this could compromise investigations.

He said Article 47 requires suspects to know the nature of an inquiry and be treated lawfully, while Articles 49 and 50 protect the rights of arrested and accused persons.

Onyango drafted a land sale agreement dated August 24, 2022, between Rose Pape, the vendor, and Julius Nyodegi, Mirjam Gutow and Colletah Nyodegi, the buyers. The vendor signed as the administrator of the estate of Rose Mwasha Pape.

She told the court that her role was limited to drafting and witnessing the agreement in her professional capacity, for which she received a fee of Sh15,000, maintaining that neither she nor her firm handled the transaction funds.

The property involved was a one-acre subdivision of a four-acre parcel. She said the buyers were aware that the land was subject to succession proceedings.

Onyango also told the court that an associate, Kanazi, was handling the matter because she had taken leave from practice to care for her ailing mother.

She argued that the vendor received the deposit and had admitted receiving the full Sh3 million, offering to refund it within 90 days. This, she maintained, demonstrated that the dispute was purely civil.

She further said she had honoured the first summons, produced documents and recorded a statement, but the DCI later issued fresh summons over the same matter without presenting new evidence.

She described the investigation as an attempt to criminalise professional conduct and intimidate a lawyer for carrying out her lawful duties.





Source link