Nairobi City County has obtained a temporary reprieve from paying more than Sh2.5 billion in compensation to the owner of Ukay Mall over the demolition of the building in 2018.
A three-judge bench of the Court of Appeal suspended the judgment that ordered the county government to compensate Kental Enterprises, ruling that the amount involved was substantial and could cripple the county’s operations if paid before the appeal is heard.
The mall was demolished in August 2018 following a government directive to pull down buildings allegedly erected on riparian land.
Following the demolition, Kental successfully sued the county government, the Attorney-General, the National Environment Management Authority and the Water Resources Management Authority.
In a judgment delivered in March 2025, the Environment and Land Court faulted the demolition and ordered the more than Sh2.5 billion compensation for the destruction of its property.
“We are told by the applicant and by the other respondents, and we agree, that this is a colossal sum of money which, if taken from the applicant which derives its revenue from public funds, might very well grind its operations to a halt,” the appellate court said.
The judges noted that the compensation would have to be drawn from public funds, making it necessary to consider and safeguard the public interest at the interlocutory stage.
They also directed Kental to ensure the intended appeal is filed within 45 days to facilitate an early determination of the dispute.
Ukay Mall housed several businesses, including the now-collapsed Nakumatt Supermarket.
“Considering that the 1st respondent’s (Kental Enterprises Ltd) petition was allowed and we have decided to stay the judgment of the trial court, it is fair in the circumstances that the intended appeal be filed within 45 days of today and be placed before the Deputy Registrar immediately thereafter for case management so that the rights of the parties are finally determined either way,” the court said.
During the 2018 demolitions, government agencies brought down hundreds of structures across Nairobi that were alleged to have encroached on river riparian reserves, wetlands and public utility land.
Ukay Mall, which housed several businesses, including the now-collapsed Nakumatt Supermarket, was among the buildings targeted. Authorities alleged that it had been constructed on a riparian reserve along River Kibarage.
The owners, however, maintained that they held valid title deeds and building approvals issued by the former Nairobi City Council in 1994 and 1995.
The ELC agreed with Kental Enterprises Ltd, finding that the demolition violated the company’s right to property.
The court further ruled that the demolition had been carried out without due process, thereby violating the company’s constitutional rights under Article 47 of the Constitution, which guarantees the right to fair administrative action.
It directed the government to compensate the company for the value of the three properties that had been demolished, with the awards totalling more than Sh2.5 billion.
The judge further ordered that, upon receiving the compensation, the company surrender the certificates of title to the Chief Land Registrar for cancellation to prevent unjust enrichment.
The county government subsequently moved to the Court of Appeal, arguing that its intended appeal raised serious and arguable issues and had high chances of success.
It said the appeal would be rendered nugatory if execution of the compensation award was not suspended pending its determination.
The county told the court that its operations were funded exclusively through public resources and that paying the award would divert money set aside for essential services, including healthcare, education, infrastructure development and waste management.
It argued that such a diversion would undermine the delivery of public services and prejudice the public interest.
Opposing the application, Kental Enterprises director Bimal Shah maintained that the demolition was unlawful and violated the company’s constitutional rights.
Mr Shah argued that the company had substantial assets, including shares in Albizzia Downs Estate Ltd, Broadways Bakery Ltd and Bakex Millers Ltd, and was therefore financially capable of refunding the compensation if the county’s appeal succeeded.